Card Condition & Grading Guide

Every card we sell is assessed by eye, by us, and photographed front and back before it is listed. This page explains exactly what our condition grades mean, what we look at when we assign one, and — just as importantly — what our grades are not.

The scale at a glance

Tap any grade to jump straight to what it means.

NM Near Mint
NM/EXC Near Mint to Excellent
EXC Excellent
EXC/LP Excellent to Lightly Played
LP Lightly Played
LP/MP Lightly Played to Moderately Played
MP Moderately Played
MP/HP Moderately to Heavily Played
HP Heavily Played

The photographs are the grade

A written grade is shorthand. It cannot capture a soft corner, a faint print line, or the precise way a swirl catches the light. The photographs on each listing are the definitive record of what you are buying, and our written grade is a summary of them. If the two ever seem to disagree, trust the photographs — and tell us, because we want to fix it.

We hold no professional grading credential. We are not PSA, BGS, CGC or ACE, and our grades are not certifications or an estimate of what a card would grade if submitted. They are our own careful, consistent opinion, applied the same way to every card in the shop.

What we look at

  • Corners — sharpness, whitening, softness, any fraying or rounding.
  • Edges — chipping, nicks, whitening along the border, wear from handling or shuffling.
  • Surface — scratches, scuffs, print lines, indentations, clouding on holo foil, any loss of gloss.
  • Centring — how evenly the artwork sits within the borders, front and back.
  • The back — vintage Japanese cards live and die by their backs. We check for scratches, scuffs and edge wear on the 旧裏 old-back print, and photograph it every time.

Our grades

NM — Near Mint

Sharp corners, clean edges, a clean surface and a clean back. Under close inspection it may show the faintest evidence of its age, but nothing you would notice holding it. As good as a card this old realistically gets.

NM/EXC — Near Mint to Excellent

Essentially Near Mint, with one small thing holding it back — a touch of softness at a single corner, the lightest edge wear, or slightly off-centre framing. Still a card that presents beautifully.

EXC — Excellent

Light, even wear consistent with careful handling. Minor corner softness or light edge whitening, a clean surface, no creasing. A strong, attractive copy.

EXC/LP — Excellent to Lightly Played

More visible wear than Excellent but not yet Lightly Played. Typically corner wear plus some edge whitening, or a small surface mark. Presents well in a sleeve.

LP — Lightly Played

Obvious but modest wear. Whitening along the edges, softened corners, light surface scratching. No significant creasing. A card that has clearly been enjoyed and kept reasonably.

LP/MP — Lightly Played to Moderately Played

Sitting between the two. Usually noticeable edge and corner wear with surface marks, or a light crease that does not break the print.

MP — Moderately Played

Significant wear. Heavier whitening, rounded corners, visible surface scratching, and often a crease or bend. Structurally sound and fully displayable, but plainly played with.

MP/HP — Moderately to Heavily Played

Heavy wear approaching the bottom of the scale. Multiple creases, substantial whitening, notable surface damage.

HP — Heavily Played

Extensive wear throughout — creasing, heavy whitening, scuffing, possible minor edge tears or small surface loss. The card is complete and intact. Often the most affordable route into a card that is otherwise out of reach.

DMG — Damaged

Beyond Heavily Played. Tears, water damage, writing, holes, or significant material loss. We list these openly and price them accordingly, because for a scarce vintage card a damaged copy is still a copy — and for many collectors that matters.

Why we use split grades, and why we use Excellent

A five-step scale forces cards into boxes they do not quite fit, and the standard shorthand is lopsided before you start. Above "played" it offers exactly one grade. Below it, three.

So we use Excellent. Between a card carrying no meaningful wear and one that has plainly been played there is a wide middle, and a great many carefully kept cards sit in it. Push them up and you flatter them; push them down and you malign them. EXC is the honest name for that ground.

Our reading is that the shorthand came from a hobby grading cards fresh from the pack, where a card is either mint or it is not. Vintage does not behave that way, and the middle is where most of it lives.

The split grades do the same work at the joins. A card sitting genuinely between Lightly Played and Moderately Played is served by neither label, so we grade it LP/MP and let the photographs settle it. Splits are used honestly, never as a way to nudge a card upward.

Things that are not damage

Vintage Japanese cards carry production characteristics that a modern eye can mistake for faults. We disclose these as features, not flaws, and grade them separately from wear:

  • Off-centre printing — the artwork sitting closer to one border. Genuine production variance from the original run, common across 1996–1999 Japanese print runs.
  • Swirl holos — the distinctive swirling foil pattern of Japan's earliest holographic cards. Sought after, not a defect.
  • Print lines and print errors — artefacts of the original printing process. Disclosed and, in some cases, collectible in their own right.
  • Glossy finish on CoroCoro and Vending cards — these were bound into magazines or dispensed from machines rather than pack-pulled. They look and wear differently from booster cards. They are not fakes.
  • No rarity symbol — an early-print characteristic on certain cards that later printings corrected. A genuine variant, often valued above the standard print.

How we pack what you buy

Sleeved, into a toploader, secured so it cannot shift, and sent in a bubble mailer or a rigid mailer depending on the size of the order — built up to a box where the order is large enough to need one. Every parcel is tracked and insured for the full value of the order. We are an online-only shop — there is no storefront and no collection in person, so everything is posted. Full detail is in our Shipping policy.

If we get it wrong

We don't accept change-of-mind returns, and condition that is visible in the listing photographs isn't grounds for one — that is the entire reason the photographs are shot the way they are.

But if a card arrives damaged, has damage the photographs did not show, isn't the card that was pictured, or isn't authentic, that is our problem to fix. Email resolutions@mementotradingco.com.au and we will refund or replace it. Please write before sending anything back.

If a parcel goes missing, or is marked as delivered but hasn't reached you, write to the same address. We will open an investigation with Australia Post and keep you updated, and what happens next follows its outcome. Your rights under the Australian Consumer Law are unaffected by anything on this page, and the full detail sits in our Returns & Refunds policy.

Unsure about a specific card before you buy? Email enquiries@mementotradingco.com.au and ask. We will happily take more photographs, at any angle you like. We would far rather answer a question than process a return.